ONLY ON ABC7NEWS.COM: Two canine deaths spark concern about lack of rules for canine trainers


SAN RAMON, Calif. (KGO) — Two Bay Space males are scheduled to reply fees Monday in Contra Costa County Superior Courtroom on fees of eight felony counts of animal abuse and neglect.

Defendant Gary Reynolds is the proprietor of NorCal Okay-9. Devon Ashby is a co-defendant on this case. He labored as a coach for NorCal Okay-9.

Prosecutors say a canine named Gunnar died whereas below the care of NorCal Okay-9. Additionally they say seven different canines below the corporate’s care have been discovered to be below excessive duress and presenting well being issues.

A choose additionally ordered Reynolds to not prepare or handle animals throughout this trial.

That is one among not less than two latest incidents in Contra Costa County by which a canine allegedly died below a coach’s care. The opposite case entails not solely the dying of a canine, however accusations of breach of contract and failure to supply providers for 2 different house owners. With an estimated 89 million pet canines on this nation, involved pet lovers and professionals are calling for extra regulation of the canine coaching business.

RELATED: Santa Clara couple says canine died in care of native coach

“Dolly, Dolly, whoa. Go get it.” Jane Creswell performs along with her canine Dolly at her dwelling in San Ramon.

She says Dolly hasn’t been the identical since being attacked by a canine’s coach’s personal canine a 12 months in the past. Jane’s different canine Kenzie died in the identical assault.

The San Ramon girl and her husband went on trip and left their canines within the care of a girl by the identify of Daybreak Smith.

“Virtually two days later I obtained a name again from her frantic, telling me that she had been strolling my canines and a pit bull got here and killed Kenzie and he or she saved Dolly,” Creswell mentioned.

Creswell mentioned Smith later admitted it was her canine, and never a pitbull, which killed Kenzie and severely injured Dolly. She believes Kenzie died at an condominium the place Smith was believed to have lived on the time.

A lawsuit filed final 12 months by one other canine proprietor in opposition to Smith accused her of breach of contract and fraud for failing to supply the providers paid for. The lawyer dropped the case when course of servers couldn’t find Smith to serve her the mandatory authorized papers.

7 On Your Aspect too tried to contact Smith for this story, however we have been unsuccessful.

Final summer time Smith did converse by telephone to ABC7 Information concerning the dying of Kenzie. She mentioned her canine should have escaped his kennel whereas she was out purchasing. Smith instructed ABC7 Information on the time she was not within the canine coaching enterprise and had no revenue to pay for Creswell’s bills. Nonetheless, she pledged to pay Creswell again for the $26,000 in vet payments for Kenzie’s care.

Up to now, Jane says she hasn’t obtained a single fee.

7 On Your Aspect discovered of not less than two different pet house owners who even have had complaints about Smith. Lucy Alvarez despatched her canine, Princess, to Smith to study higher social abilities with plans to ship a second canine for coaching as properly. Lucy says she reluctantly allowed Smith to make use of a shock collar on Princess after Smith satisfied her the shock can be minimal. She regretted the choice.

“The second time was worse,” mentioned Alvarez. “The primary time she was a really nervous little canine, however the second time she was a really scared little canine.”

Alvarez mentioned she signed a one 12 months contract, however coaching abruptly ended after lower than 5 months when she says Smith not returned any calls or emails.

Angela Maxwell additionally employed Smith to coach her canine Kona to show her how one can higher socialize with different canines. She paid for six classes and likewise allowed using a shock collar. A number of months later the 2 exchanged emails throughout which Smith apologized saying she had been out of city and provided to finish the lessons with Maxwell’s canine.

Maxwell says she gave up on scheduling after Smith did not get again to her once more after that.

On the SPCA in San Francisco, canine trainers are each accredited and authorized by credible canine coaching associations. That is not at all times the case.

“Sadly your canines should be licensed, however your canine trainers don’t,” mentioned Ariel Stephens of the SPCA.

The SPCA considers shock collars a software of final resort.

“Canine study higher with issues that encourage them to bolster the habits you need to see extra and issues that trigger ache and concern have the other impact and do not construct new behaviors,” mentioned Stephens.

A board member with the Affiliation of Skilled Canine Trainers believes shock collars ought to solely be used when different coaching strategies have failed. His group is asking for extra oversight of its business.

“I consider the vast majority of canine trainers are on the lookout for rules, however what that appears like remains to be up within the air,” mentioned Nic Hof.

7 On Your Aspect checked with 9 colleges and organizations which the SPCA or Affiliation of Skilled Canine Trainers say supply revered certifications for canine trainers. Eight of the 9 have gotten again to us, and none have any document of Smith being credentialed.

This, as Creswell’s canine Dolly lives with a respiration tube in her neck and remains to be recovering from her accidents from one 12 months in the past.

“We have to carry some form of laws or one thing within the state of California that has some form of parameters for what sort of {qualifications} a canine coach acquired to have,” mentioned Creswell.

We’ve an inventory of respected accreditations and organizations from each the SPCA and Associations of Skilled Canine trainers, plus an inventory of questions you need to ask a canine coach earlier than hiring one at

These teams supply revered certifications for canine trainers. This record compiled from suggestions of the San Francisco SPCA and Affiliation of Skilled Canine Trainers.

  • Certification Council for Skilled Canine Trainers
  • Animal Habits Faculty
  • Animal Habits Institute
  • Bergin College of Canine Research
  • Canine Habits Associates
  • Academy of Canine Trainers
  • Pet Skilled Guild
  • The Worldwide Affiliation of Animal Habits Consultants
  • Pet Skilled Accreditation Board

Listed below are questions you need to ask earlier than hiring a canine coach

  • What sort of gear will you be utilizing on my canine?
  • What’s going to occur when my canine does one thing properly?
  • What’s going to occur if my canine does not do one thing properly?
  • How will you realize when my canine is confused?
  • How will you deal with my canine’s stress?
  • Can I be current throughout the whole class?
  • What training does your canine coach have?
  • The place did they study to turn out to be a canine coach?
  • What further coaching does your canine coach have?
  • What precisely will they be doing when coaching your canine?
  • Does your canine coach have any canine coaching certifications?

Check out extra tales and movies by Michael Finney and seven On Your Aspect.

Copyright © 2019 KGO-TV. All Rights Reserved.